Farm Contractor & Large Scale Farmer
    Twitter LinkedIn
    • FREE Email Newsletters
    • About Us
    • Advertise
    • Subscribe
    • Contact Us
    Twitter LinkedIn
    Podcast
    Farm Contractor & Large Scale Farmer
    • News
      • Arable & Agronomy
      • Dealership News
      • Environmental Land Management Scheme/Policy
      • Event News
      • Health & Safety
      • Machinery
      • People
      • World News
    • Farm Machinery
      • Amenity & Maintenance
      • Cultivations
      • Drilling
      • Grassland Equipment
      • Harvesting
      • Muck & Slurry
      • Sprayers
      • Telehandlers
      • Tractors
      • Tractor of the Year
      • Tyres & Tracks
      • Whatever happened to?
    • Precision Farming
    • Markets & Policy
    • Profiles
      • National Arable and Grassland Awards
      • Company Profiles
      • Reader Profiles
    • Livestock
      • Beef
      • Dairy
      • Sheep
    • Magazines
      1. November 2026
      2. October 2026
      3. September 2026
      4. August 2026
      5. 2026 Drills and Seeds supplement
      6. July 2026
      7. June 2026
      8. May 2026
      9. April 2026
      10. March 2026
      11. 2026 Tyre Developments supplement
      12. February 2026
      13. January 2026
      14. December 2025
      15. November 2025
      16. 2025 Agritechnica preview
      17. October 2025 issue
      18. September 2025 issue
      19. August 2025 issue
      20. 2025 Drills and Seeds supplement
      21. July 2025 issue
      22. June 2025 issue
      23. Cereals event guide 2025
      24. May 2025 issue
      25. April 2025 issue
      26. March 2025 issue
      27. 2025 Tyre Developments supplement
      28. February 2025 issue
      29. National Arable and Grassland Awards supplement
      30. January 2025 issue
      31. December 2024 issue
      32. November 2024 issue
      33. October 2024 issue
      34. September 2024 issue
      35. August 2024 Issue
      36. 2024 Drills and Seeds supplement
      37. July 2024 Issue
      38. Cereals Supplement
      39. June 2024 Issue
      40. May 2024 Issue
      41. April 2024 Issue
      42. Tyres and Tracks Supplement
      43. March 2024 Issue
      44. National Arable & Grassland Award – Meet the Finalists
      45. February 2024 Issue
      46. January 2024 Issue
      47. December 2023
      48. Agritechnica Preview Supplement
      49. November 2023
      50. October 2023
      Featured

      November 2026 issue available now

      By Matthew TiltNovember 1, 2026
      Recent

      November 2026 issue available now

      November 1, 2026

      October 2026 issue available now

      October 1, 2026

      September 2026 issue available now

      September 1, 2026
    • Events
    • Podcast
    Farm Contractor & Large Scale Farmer
    Markets & Policy

    New report highlights need for food security

    Matthew TiltBy Matthew TiltApril 8, 20265 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email
    AdobeStock

    A report from HCR Law has stated that food security is being held back by a range of legal and regulatory barriers. In the foreword, Rory Hutchings, partner and head of agriculture and estates at HCR Law, says that government incentives for the environment had taken priority over food production, which, combined with renewables projects on Grade 1 land, is eroding farmland.

    He added that there is potential within the sector, both for food security and the sector’s contribution to GDP, but this requires a strategy of support which enables farmers to boost productivity on the best land, while using less productive areas for environmental gain.

    The report highlights the volatility of farm incomes. While the Total Income From Farming (TIFF) has significantly increased since the Covid-19 pandemic (£5.1b in 2020 to £7.7b in 2024), sharp changes year-to-year and between livestock and arable incomes make it difficult for businesses to plan with confidence. Defra’s Farm Business Income (FBI) figures show that arable farm incomes dropped by around 73% between 2023 and 2024, and despite improvements, the figure of £49,700 in the latest statistics was bolstered by diversification and agri-environment schemes. Arable farming on its own was still considered a loss-maker.

    HCR Law states that this raises fundamental questions about the sustainability of domestic food production and self-sufficiency. Currently, the UK can produce around 60% of its total food requirements. Quoted in the report, Abi Reader, president of NFU Cymru, says that policy discussions often overlook primary production.

    “Too often, government focuses on the food and drinks sector, and that has been the area of conversation instead of farmers and growers,” she says. “The logistics of food production and how that produce arrives in the shop are not given the prominence they deserve.”

    Long-term planning

    Cath Crowther, regional director for the East of England, Country Land and Business Association (CLA), highlights the need for a reset on water abstraction licences. “…agriculture is often at the bottom of the priority list compared to other users. There’s a huge opportunity for us to be producing more fruit and vegetables in the county.”

    She adds that wider abstraction windows, during flooding, for example, and greater planning permissions for on-farm reservoirs would go some way to boosting productivity, but that growers struggle to get the various departments to align. The CLA’s own Rural Powerhouse report notes that the rural economy is around 16% less productive than the national average. If efforts were made to close this gap, it would add around £4.3b to UK Gross Value Added.

    The report notes that policy around planning permissions has become increasingly complex, with local authorities interpreting rules differently or rigidly adhering to outdated local plans, which leads to unnecessary delays and refusals. The piecemeal process of applying for a change of use, then adding an extension, as an example, incurs multiple fees and prolongs the process. HCR Law calls for regulations to be streamlined and guidance to be improved to ensure consistency between councils to encourage innovation.

    Cutting red tape

    Farming is one of the most heavily regulated sectors in the country, as it spans agriculture, waste and transportation, and the UK has some of the most stringent standards. EU rules still in place are ‘gold-plated’, whereas member states have some discretion in how these are implemented, according to the report.

    Aled Owen, partner, agriculture regulatory, HCR Law, notes that proper regulation is important, and that the high standards of the UK across welfare, environmental compliance and quality could be beneficial to international trade. However, the resulting increase in production costs has the adverse effect of making imports cheaper. “The question needs to be: can higher costs associated with higher regulation be justified, or is there a case for a more nuanced approach as seen in many of the European agricultural economies?

    “…regulation must protect food safety and the environment without creating avoidable cost and uncertainty that undermine competitiveness.”

    Price takers

    Steve Thomas, partner, commercial, HCR Law, highlights the restrictive nature of supply contracts that do not take into account unexpected market shifts or adverse weather events. Dairy farmers who have invested heavily in equipment and livestock may find themselves selling at a loss or face non-compliance penalties should the buyer reduce their order or if the market changes.

    The report calls for more flexible terms that allow for changes in supply and demand, as well as offering fairer exit clauses. Looking again at the dairy industry, the Fair Dealings Obligations (Milk) Regulations 2024 aim to improve the imbalance of power between primary producers and buyers, though its impact is yet to be seen.

    “Primary producers, such as farmers, are often ‘price takers’ rather than ‘price setters’, making it difficult to negotiate from a position of strength, particularly with perishable goods. What the sector needs most is stability, fairness, and transparency.”

    An even footing

    The report concludes that the industry is at a crossroads, with sustainable farming only possible when farms are financially viable. “UK farmers have the capability, ingenuity and appetite to deliver more… but cannot do so while navigating systems that limit growth, distort risk and stifle innovation.

    “To secure a resilient agricultural future, we believe there needs to be greater emphasis on food security, placing food production on at least an equal footing with environmental policy and creating the conditions for profitable, forward-looking farm businesses.

    “That means regulatory proportionality, a planning system that supports diversification, realistic labour solutions, fairer contractual relationships and sustained support for the adoption of productivity-enhancing technologies.”

    Tweet
    Share
    Share
    Pin
    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email
    Previous ArticleLimagrain launches farmer-led demo network
    Next Article PGRO to showcase changes to Yield Enhancement Network
    Matthew Tilt
    • Twitter
    • LinkedIn

    Machinery editor for Farm Contractor & Large Scale Farmer. Matt has worked as an agricultural machinery journalist for five years, following time spent in his family’s Worcestershire contracting business. When he’s not driving or writing about the latest farm equipment, he can be found in his local cinema, or with his headphones in, reading a good book.

    Read Similar Stories

    Why research is key to successful diversification

    October 21, 2026

    Farmers urged to explore alternatives after SFI window closes

    September 29, 2026

    Farmers left ‘high, dry and desperate’ over SFI divide

    September 29, 2026
    Most Read Stories

    FPT invests in hybrid engines

    November 19, 2026

    New AI camera system available on Ferri mulchers

    November 19, 2026

    Faresin shows pre-series autonomous feeder wagon

    November 19, 2026
    Farm Contractor & Large Scale Farmer

    The UK's leading agricultural machinery journal

    Twitter LinkedIn
    © 2024 MA Agriculture Ltd, a Mark Allen Group company

    Privacy Policy | Cookies Policy | Terms & Conditions

    • Farmers Weekly
    • AA Farmer
    • Poultry News
    • Pig World

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.